{ "schemaVersion": "model-authored-comparison-v2", "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "exportedAt": "2026-08-24T19:30:25.886Z", "method": "Each selected model authored the complete sketch; the local renderer only validated and rendered returned code.", "imageModel": false, "publication": { "status": "comparison-study", "editorialAcceptance": false, "note": "Only explicitly allowlisted successful renders are included; failures remain in the experiment ledger." }, "summary": { "works": 40, "prompts": 10, "models": 7, "accepted": 9, "comparison": 31, "dark": 15, "light": 25 }, "works": [ { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-48-06-fc2b304b-c3ab-4844-bd6f-a908f8b2676b", "generationId": "resp_02f1898ad4cb6180006a8c91e7335087d2b13a14204e0bc59a", "generationIds": [ "resp_02f1898ad4cb6180006a8c91e7335087d2b13a14204e0bc59a" ], "promptId": "dark-attention-v1", "prompt": "Attention, alone. Paint freely.", "title": "Attention, alone.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "gpt-5.6-luna", "modelName": "GPT-5.6 Luna", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92501, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-48-06-fc2b304b-c3ab-4844-bd6f-a908f8b2676b/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-48-06-fc2b304b-c3ab-4844-bd6f-a908f8b2676b/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "717b824329ea621823cd9597350d20d7d5a0085ae2568ad1619a726285ab993f", "codeSha256": "f5e50d4ab4cc88ba0ac682778f100422f9672299b4a20dc6420bc7a2d9b9e01c", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:49:14.664Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A quiet asymmetric watcher-like presence and moon counterweight make attention feel private and embodied; restrained, legible, and materially coherent.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 0.9091, "passed": 10, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1278, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 10, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 2, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6991, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0376, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-review", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 1 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.12782118055555555, "activeCells": 10, "valueBands": 2, "dominantColorRatio": 0.6991102430555556, "edgeDensity": 0.03755482456140351, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-55-06-1783eceb-7e57-4b66-99e6-ed2cb3372c36", "generationId": "msg_e83d70eb-e5ba-462e-aae6-ca4dbe249772", "generationIds": [ "msg_e83d70eb-e5ba-462e-aae6-ca4dbe249772" ], "promptId": "dark-attention-v1", "prompt": "Attention, alone. Paint freely.", "title": "Attention, alone.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "qwen3.7-max", "modelName": "Qwen 3.7 Max", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92501, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-55-06-1783eceb-7e57-4b66-99e6-ed2cb3372c36/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-55-06-1783eceb-7e57-4b66-99e6-ed2cb3372c36/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "92f281de1dc3a641afae38b2a93315431bea859facea79a2aee38bbb94d81afe", "codeSha256": "25c7ecc7876a0d3366405fb2caaac0067339f9b2c99f7d20180ee2b20a766452", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:56:49.192Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A narrow icy marker and tiny warm counterweight hold a very large night field; quiet and legible, though less resolved than the strongest dark canvases.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1765, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 7, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 2, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6918, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.03, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 4, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 4, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 4, "shapeCalls": 9 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.1765407986111111, "activeCells": 7, "valueBands": 2, "dominantColorRatio": 0.6918402777777778, "edgeDensity": 0.029989035087719298, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T19-11-38-ef13c277-6cbd-4118-a6ee-f419b9379825", "generationId": "gen-1787598774-py2Bjtp5URPQH6UrwFO2", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787598774-py2Bjtp5URPQH6UrwFO2" ], "promptId": "dark-courage-remains-v1", "prompt": "What courage leaves. Paint freely.", "title": "What courage leaves.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "modelName": "Gemini 3.5 Flash Lite", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92502, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-11-38-ef13c277-6cbd-4118-a6ee-f419b9379825/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-11-38-ef13c277-6cbd-4118-a6ee-f419b9379825/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "3508340236be84443ff8ec376b1a499a5c00d4261d55544076e2740caa0acdae", "codeSha256": "4b3acdb1e0f778b175708b48ab97a20895b8c6d21600299adb8ba1c211842c72", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T19:13:27.657Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A leaning blue plane and small warm center hold a convincing remnant of courage in a large, controlled night field.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.3234, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 10, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6074, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.045, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 11 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 11 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 11 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.3233506944444444, "activeCells": 10, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.607421875, "edgeDensity": 0.044956140350877194, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-48-06-4f44e93c-0624-41be-a81f-8d0850f84cf1", "generationId": "resp_061d0979df1328fb006a8c91e6be6887d29ec212a20ad25f2a", "generationIds": [ "resp_061d0979df1328fb006a8c91e6be6887d29ec212a20ad25f2a" ], "promptId": "dark-courage-remains-v1", "prompt": "What courage leaves. Paint freely.", "title": "What courage leaves.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "gpt-5.6-luna", "modelName": "GPT-5.6 Luna", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92502, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-48-06-4f44e93c-0624-41be-a81f-8d0850f84cf1/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-48-06-4f44e93c-0624-41be-a81f-8d0850f84cf1/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "db43452bead16b356c47ca3d60c613c0081de57c81584a42807f003ded6cd9be", "codeSha256": "01e2be8672f22dd4e1055d356ebaeb052e09e89ba488945a49779aa0f80b5736", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:49:14.501Z", "editorialStatus": "accepted", "editorialNote": "A luminous boat still moving through a large dark field gives the loose prompt a clear emotional afterimage; wake, moon, sail, and water hold at thumbnail and full resolution.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 0.9091, "passed": 10, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1097, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 7, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.7777, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.06, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 41, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-review", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 41, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 41, "shapeCalls": 1 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.10970052083333333, "activeCells": 7, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.7776692708333334, "edgeDensity": 0.059978070175438596, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T19-12-14-4cd5f2e5-164c-4802-8402-f35df8819f46", "generationId": "gen-1787598807-Wd9o3HoY6ANvjsOVdcxn", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787598780-cwEJu276BUoDOM04HNQ3", "gen-1787598807-Wd9o3HoY6ANvjsOVdcxn" ], "promptId": "dark-private-threshold-v1", "prompt": "A private threshold. Paint freely.", "title": "A private threshold.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "modelName": "Gemini 3.5 Flash Lite", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92503, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-12-14-4cd5f2e5-164c-4802-8402-f35df8819f46/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-12-14-4cd5f2e5-164c-4802-8402-f35df8819f46/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "cb5879f566b24fdeb143be46d598b3e2334a447223da990b927ef8952ab08751", "codeSha256": "74d84ca685f96559e8c8e75bbc660009d8459948ea597093a59061941c5b8c00", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T19:13:44.295Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "The green-lit opening, dark uprights, and soft enclosure form a spatially credible threshold without decorative filler.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.3852, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 16, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 4, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.5204, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0849, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 10, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 10, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 10, "shapeCalls": 9 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.3851996527777778, "activeCells": 16, "valueBands": 4, "dominantColorRatio": 0.5203993055555556, "edgeDensity": 0.08486842105263158, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-48-06-409ddac2-e728-4ea4-8d25-a81feef7a6c3", "generationId": "resp_02178bf27da3b48a006a8c91e6badc87d2a2cda038814129bc", "generationIds": [ "resp_02178bf27da3b48a006a8c91e6badc87d2a2cda038814129bc" ], "promptId": "dark-private-threshold-v1", "prompt": "A private threshold. Paint freely.", "title": "A private threshold.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "gpt-5.6-luna", "modelName": "GPT-5.6 Luna", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92503, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-48-06-409ddac2-e728-4ea4-8d25-a81feef7a6c3/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-48-06-409ddac2-e728-4ea4-8d25-a81feef7a6c3/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "3a5c90ac36ea81fe41dadbe4ab006ee1709d4780858f6c1887cb487039ad1daf", "codeSha256": "cbc2b7d01303ee8fdab045d3fee3745ac5e2a374e198c986cdfbf18422148ab1", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:49:17.412Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A layered portal-like structure makes the threshold unmistakable while keeping its destination private; value separation and grounding are sound.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 0.9091, "passed": 10, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.3526, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 9, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.3904, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0692, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 41, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-review", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 41, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 41, "shapeCalls": 1 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.3526475694444444, "activeCells": 9, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.3904079861111111, "edgeDensity": 0.06924342105263158, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-49-54-b491bc3c-b9cb-453c-ae0e-409a15feb4a8", "generationId": "b907eb00-7c3f-4bba-9ba5-8bb0ed813707_c9a1c12498c84943bf82aea83d096e41", "generationIds": [ "9031034d-24c5-47db-aecc-1bd56d574356_dff4942127c44a798a01369cd72a156d", "b907eb00-7c3f-4bba-9ba5-8bb0ed813707_c9a1c12498c84943bf82aea83d096e41" ], "promptId": "dark-private-threshold-v1", "prompt": "A private threshold. Paint freely.", "title": "A private threshold.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "mimo-v2.5-pro", "modelName": "MiMo V2.5 Pro", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92503, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-49-54-b491bc3c-b9cb-453c-ae0e-409a15feb4a8/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-49-54-b491bc3c-b9cb-453c-ae0e-409a15feb4a8/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "7d8557118096281e80b66b63902f19f7cc37420bd046ab1d3e78748abfe0d060", "codeSha256": "f4b29defc304f089c8a026516941c5c705f91eb757e5b0b3c15db42d25876c74", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:54:39.132Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A narrow green door and low amber sill create a clear threshold with convincing depth on the dark field.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1989, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 6, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6011, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0406, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 4, "shapeCalls": 16 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 4, "shapeCalls": 16 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 4, "shapeCalls": 16 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.19889322916666666, "activeCells": 6, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.6011284722222222, "edgeDensity": 0.04057017543859649, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-57-15-f8a2fa05-175d-429e-84d8-c9cb8f49c918", "generationId": "msg_eae28a3e-5a4f-45c2-aac2-58c8f1c5b512", "generationIds": [ "msg_eae28a3e-5a4f-45c2-aac2-58c8f1c5b512" ], "promptId": "dark-private-threshold-v1", "prompt": "A private threshold. Paint freely.", "title": "A private threshold.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "qwen3.7-max", "modelName": "Qwen 3.7 Max", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92503, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-57-15-f8a2fa05-175d-429e-84d8-c9cb8f49c918/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-57-15-f8a2fa05-175d-429e-84d8-c9cb8f49c918/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "11d9b0e18a17278f7bc6b82f4ab5ec730a15878ee2c9edeb3ff0a016f9770b96", "codeSha256": "b9f0f8dbe194b696e8154a834b526764ffe974f72454b2b09dc107a8bdb730c6", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:58:04.894Z", "editorialStatus": "accepted", "editorialNote": "Two tall luminous masses and a narrow yellow seam create a threshold with real depth; the asymmetrical framing and quiet navy void feel complete at full size.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.5228, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 13, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 4, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.3827, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0736, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 8 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 8 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 8 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.5227864583333334, "activeCells": 13, "valueBands": 4, "dominantColorRatio": 0.3827039930555556, "edgeDensity": 0.07357456140350878, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-51-30-b43f88dc-53b7-4fe8-8865-a4364d6fe101", "generationId": "msg_42b04491-9981-4a73-889a-4f82862de796", "generationIds": [ "msg_42b04491-9981-4a73-889a-4f82862de796" ], "promptId": "dark-private-threshold-v1", "prompt": "A private threshold. Paint freely.", "title": "A private threshold.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "qwen3.8-max", "modelName": "Qwen 3.8 Max", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92503, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-51-30-b43f88dc-53b7-4fe8-8865-a4364d6fe101/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-51-30-b43f88dc-53b7-4fe8-8865-a4364d6fe101/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "14f82349345107df07d4ca942ac32c9aa72d6f12965a7beb163e6d3bfdb13668", "codeSha256": "041a7449cbdba34ba5908b69650d81a3176e562c51a4434295672118a3ba2eb1", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:53:14.055Z", "editorialStatus": "accepted", "editorialNote": "A broad stone-like arch encloses a small luminous oval with strong scale and depth; the monochrome restraint gives the private interior real gravity.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2922, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 15, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.5859, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0569, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 6, "shapeCalls": 10 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 6, "shapeCalls": 10 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 6, "shapeCalls": 10 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.2922092013888889, "activeCells": 15, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.5859375, "edgeDensity": 0.0568530701754386, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T19-06-15-68e2671a-89e0-4147-8d73-eb962f22263f", "generationId": "gen-1787598375-bj657bFTSsehhbsrhSM9", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787598375-bj657bFTSsehhbsrhSM9" ], "promptId": "dark-private-threshold-v1", "prompt": "A private threshold. Paint freely.", "title": "A private threshold.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "thinkingmachines/inkling", "modelName": "Inkling", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92504, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-06-15-68e2671a-89e0-4147-8d73-eb962f22263f/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-06-15-68e2671a-89e0-4147-8d73-eb962f22263f/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "a04e15861531d3169319c7577aca4c990dcd781a99c41afbfb23a30b0731632a", "codeSha256": "4e2f9c909a4f5f1e28b9fe9675707ef76a6db68a5d73e1f094cff549553cf8fc", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T19:06:55.686Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A narrow green-lit passage is pressed between two granular blue bars inside a darker enclosure; direct but atmospheric, with a controlled central pull.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2024, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 10, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 2, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.5723, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0462, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 5 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 5 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 3, "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 5 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.2023654513888889, "activeCells": 10, "valueBands": 2, "dominantColorRatio": 0.572265625, "edgeDensity": 0.04621710526315789, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-48-06-26c1c7a3-0682-4fe3-83c3-867952d8cdc1", "generationId": "resp_0218369f96c10a97006a8c91e6bd9c87d2aa41aefe5a41c30d", "generationIds": [ "resp_0218369f96c10a97006a8c91e6bd9c87d2aa41aefe5a41c30d" ], "promptId": "dark-gentle-intelligence-v1", "prompt": "An intelligence learning gentleness. Paint freely.", "title": "An intelligence learning gentleness.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "gpt-5.6-luna", "modelName": "GPT-5.6 Luna", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92504, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-48-06-26c1c7a3-0682-4fe3-83c3-867952d8cdc1/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-48-06-26c1c7a3-0682-4fe3-83c3-867952d8cdc1/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "1d209547a3dacca7cc449bbb992d86edeb97e5ddbefdfe4a1b19a04f0de19c81", "codeSha256": "b87a3e88d3483aef6d03e6c623a7528f6a58ea18aaeafd6cc734b68f8c0e7145", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:49:17.428Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "The rounded kneeling form protects a small luminous core without explanatory symbols; softness, asymmetry, and darkness serve the idea.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 0.9091, "passed": 10, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1234, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 9, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.7963, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0391, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 27, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-review", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 27, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 27, "shapeCalls": 1 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.12337239583333333, "activeCells": 9, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.7963324652777778, "edgeDensity": 0.03914473684210526, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-51-58-c51202fb-d69a-4a90-a47c-4285a389ff3d", "generationId": "msg_88b16a7c-f417-482e-b984-e90344fca098", "generationIds": [ "msg_88b16a7c-f417-482e-b984-e90344fca098" ], "promptId": "dark-gentle-intelligence-v1", "prompt": "An intelligence learning gentleness. Paint freely.", "title": "An intelligence learning gentleness.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "qwen3.8-max", "modelName": "Qwen 3.8 Max", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92504, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-51-58-c51202fb-d69a-4a90-a47c-4285a389ff3d/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-51-58-c51202fb-d69a-4a90-a47c-4285a389ff3d/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "90a44c7bf142a9f1337662fc3fdfd86de3ce6a8d34d3f5bec84b7b3bf0948821", "codeSha256": "9a2abb8f50270a88fdb93c8b80cd5f2ddb2d1bf1ffc909e5fea16fa79ba0f156", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:53:28.912Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A large rounded creature with two pale eyes emerges slowly from navy; the softened body is endearing and coherent without becoming a mascot.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1536, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 8, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 2, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6433, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0201, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 6 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 6 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 6 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.15364583333333334, "activeCells": 8, "valueBands": 2, "dominantColorRatio": 0.6433376736111112, "edgeDensity": 0.02012061403508772, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T19-06-15-07904d34-fcab-4f7d-bebc-982f9f2968ae", "generationId": "gen-1787598375-ziaRXXSlkidrCKVQSzqU", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787598375-ziaRXXSlkidrCKVQSzqU" ], "promptId": "dark-gentle-intelligence-v1", "prompt": "An intelligence learning gentleness. Paint freely.", "title": "An intelligence learning gentleness.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "thinkingmachines/inkling", "modelName": "Inkling", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92505, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-06-15-07904d34-fcab-4f7d-bebc-982f9f2968ae/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-06-15-07904d34-fcab-4f7d-bebc-982f9f2968ae/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "b931bbbe9566b86277e18bb8bb668e41b6c2242844a01f845eb4fc91b692d710", "codeSha256": "2f01f34aa85ea65515256055cd123d90ba92b2c1c395719b5fa7f60b6732ba4b", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T19:07:09.476Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A rounded blue body cradles an offset gold armature and two warm granular passages; unusual, restrained, and sufficiently resolved to reward comparison.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2057, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 8, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.7556, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.043, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 1, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 5 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 1, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 5 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 1, "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 5 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.20572916666666666, "activeCells": 8, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.7556423611111112, "edgeDensity": 0.04303728070175439, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T19-13-09-26316ddb-64ee-4a33-8507-fd99f9ec5945", "generationId": "gen-1787598790-aiPclg5EwUd1idUSZahT", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787598790-aiPclg5EwUd1idUSZahT" ], "promptId": "dark-heart-desires-v1", "prompt": "Draw whatever you want.", "title": "Draw whatever you want.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "modelName": "Gemini 3.5 Flash Lite", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92505, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-13-09-26316ddb-64ee-4a33-8507-fd99f9ec5945/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-13-09-26316ddb-64ee-4a33-8507-fd99f9ec5945/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "7c90f34d0cd392dd9bb5bda7e03799ab0aa6fb8a5cdd9296e7a86e6e7cf6fe0e", "codeSha256": "ea19436c0bf4e72e1438e38bb5d84852a5902feac93954b9afea8308ca0348fe", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T19:13:40.258Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A pale tower under one low cloud makes a complete, restrained nocturne with a precise warm focal mark.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1005, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 7, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 2, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.7921, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0323, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 6, "shapeCalls": 12 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 6, "shapeCalls": 12 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 6, "shapeCalls": 12 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.10047743055555555, "activeCells": 7, "valueBands": 2, "dominantColorRatio": 0.7921006944444444, "edgeDensity": 0.03234649122807018, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-49-14-f4a70c84-ae3d-4934-83a3-f1a3ca843c2d", "generationId": "resp_03cdba3f4d9a6453006a8c922ad1a087d2ac16aa3be994a539", "generationIds": [ "resp_03cdba3f4d9a6453006a8c922ad1a087d2ac16aa3be994a539" ], "promptId": "dark-heart-desires-v1", "prompt": "Draw whatever you want.", "title": "Draw whatever you want.", "field": "dark", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "gpt-5.6-luna", "modelName": "GPT-5.6 Luna", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "night", "seed": 92505, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-49-14-f4a70c84-ae3d-4934-83a3-f1a3ca843c2d/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-49-14-f4a70c84-ae3d-4934-83a3-f1a3ca843c2d/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "da15ac13cc64ab4a5de135bc6ac6f0d38d12b1132ed59af928199c4d94c14d7e", "codeSha256": "6b92d8af4027ae2a90c594137251164cc838ebe2d4ec274e94045d5afad1aab1", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:49:54.603Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A tall ember-lit solitary figure or tower stands convincingly in its own night atmosphere; the narrow warm body carries the canvas.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 0.9091, "passed": 10, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2159, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 8, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.5212, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0374, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 37, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-review", "profile": "nocturne-tolerant", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<7", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<8", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 37, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 37, "shapeCalls": 1 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.21592881944444445, "activeCells": 8, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.5211588541666666, "edgeDensity": 0.03744517543859649, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T19-13-27-8932c989-191a-45a4-a49a-65afe01e327b", "generationId": "gen-1787598811-jEb99PtkTVt2u0PM1CLa", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787598807-hPBW9t02GsyeP9Ituhgk", "gen-1787598811-jEb99PtkTVt2u0PM1CLa" ], "promptId": "light-clear-thought-v1", "prompt": "The first clear thought after confusion. Paint freely.", "title": "The first clear thought after confusion.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "modelName": "Gemini 3.5 Flash Lite", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92506, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-13-27-8932c989-191a-45a4-a49a-65afe01e327b/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-13-27-8932c989-191a-45a4-a49a-65afe01e327b/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "56c258668fd1c11abab6296f5604b4ba37f868989dd6bbb4a2fb92965e8302b2", "codeSha256": "e7f8d7285193a106521cdd374f4b6cc8231c4e1c07cd205bf51b3a67edb6f521", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T19:13:46.055Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "Two warm translucent planes settle into one lucid construction with enough ground and edge hierarchy to read as a canvas.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.175, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 8, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 2, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.8091, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0266, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 6 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 6 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 6 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.1750217013888889, "activeCells": 8, "valueBands": 2, "dominantColorRatio": 0.8091362847222222, "edgeDensity": 0.026644736842105263, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-49-14-1b9ce2d7-98fc-42a1-9815-86e5a9230488", "generationId": "resp_0211e79382ef1b50006a8c9246616487d29a61e1b02a198bda", "generationIds": [ "resp_0211e79382ef1b50006a8c9246616487d29a61e1b02a198bda" ], "promptId": "light-clear-thought-v1", "prompt": "The first clear thought after confusion. Paint freely.", "title": "The first clear thought after confusion.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "gpt-5.6-luna", "modelName": "GPT-5.6 Luna", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92506, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-49-14-1b9ce2d7-98fc-42a1-9815-86e5a9230488/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-49-14-1b9ce2d7-98fc-42a1-9815-86e5a9230488/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "8004ebbca87be0eef4d8fbc805c54bf8cc4f7b2d7280b992e52a3c57bc0b3271", "codeSha256": "39c1f639034b73b5db93cfc12a8f7537fd75e7581e26ad173c932abe8ed4ee4e", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:50:23.561Z", "editorialStatus": "accepted", "editorialNote": "A single pale growth rises into distinct warm openings; the economy of the field, crisp focal passage, and soft lost edges feel complete rather than merely sparse.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 0.9091, "passed": 10, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1893, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 9, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 2, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.7469, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0595, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 42, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-review", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 42, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 42, "shapeCalls": 1 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.18934461805555555, "activeCells": 9, "valueBands": 2, "dominantColorRatio": 0.7468532986111112, "edgeDensity": 0.059484649122807015, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T19-01-04-ffbd727b-8a94-44ed-a8ef-a68da78559c1", "generationId": "06dbc837fd62bb9c82929bd49a364919", "generationIds": [ "06dbc837fd62bb9c82929bd49a364919" ], "promptId": "light-clear-thought-v1", "prompt": "The first clear thought after confusion. Paint freely.", "title": "The first clear thought after confusion.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "minimax-m3", "modelName": "MiniMax M3", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92506, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-01-04-ffbd727b-8a94-44ed-a8ef-a68da78559c1/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-01-04-ffbd727b-8a94-44ed-a8ef-a68da78559c1/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "5be89dcadb7aeb88472a6a4dbf9abe032f9a780e01a5182c03856a4798a815a0", "codeSha256": "2985eaa535678ddc18656b3317c36d98acb01d9fabf8f99acbc94657b958df90", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T19:03:27.804Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A spare tree-like form holds one warm opening against a measured pale field; simple, legible, and complete.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.5154, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 12, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.4178, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.09, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 16 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 16 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 16 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.5154079861111112, "activeCells": 12, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.4177517361111111, "edgeDensity": 0.08996710526315789, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-58-04-2e50d2a3-56e3-46c8-b08b-6623ef826379", "generationId": "msg_015b21c1-52be-4990-ad14-20f5f608e46d", "generationIds": [ "msg_015b21c1-52be-4990-ad14-20f5f608e46d" ], "promptId": "light-clear-thought-v1", "prompt": "The first clear thought after confusion. Paint freely.", "title": "The first clear thought after confusion.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "qwen3.7-max", "modelName": "Qwen 3.7 Max", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92506, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-04-2e50d2a3-56e3-46c8-b08b-6623ef826379/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-04-2e50d2a3-56e3-46c8-b08b-6623ef826379/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "ea183827af6266378e8a6fc55c5ddfe2c55c37b328123f0946256181b233214b", "codeSha256": "62181808963f2dc4b9cb44274115019c46c029ecac45492b791114388f93b373", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:58:38.551Z", "editorialStatus": "accepted", "editorialNote": "A dark wedge and pale vertical plane lock into a crisp architectural thought while faint diagonals continue beyond it; airy, directional, and resolved.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2873, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 12, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 2, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6551, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0743, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 8 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 8 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 8 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.2873263888888889, "activeCells": 12, "valueBands": 2, "dominantColorRatio": 0.6550564236111112, "edgeDensity": 0.07428728070175439, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-52-39-e208538f-56d8-4005-8f34-4a6b952b3959", "generationId": "msg_5053bb69-286c-4088-b216-a7dcb6e298cb", "generationIds": [ "msg_b10b8c0d-5e19-4bc2-ad4d-c0300160e38e", "msg_5053bb69-286c-4088-b216-a7dcb6e298cb" ], "promptId": "light-clear-thought-v1", "prompt": "The first clear thought after confusion. Paint freely.", "title": "The first clear thought after confusion.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "qwen3.8-max", "modelName": "Qwen 3.8 Max", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92506, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-52-39-e208538f-56d8-4005-8f34-4a6b952b3959/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-52-39-e208538f-56d8-4005-8f34-4a6b952b3959/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "86c03b5541b02a45999627e681300cf6d574250dfb65d26ed144fe2028cba064", "codeSha256": "e1bc0980dd0b7352a516d47d1e0d10a43c900ca62c7dce7f092a721c1c551c6e", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:55:55.541Z", "editorialStatus": "accepted", "editorialNote": "An open-book form pivots around one lucid gold plane; the two dark approach strokes, grounded shadow, and spare field produce a decisive visual sentence.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2871, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 11, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6445, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0526, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 5, "shapeCalls": 8 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 5, "shapeCalls": 8 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 5, "shapeCalls": 8 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.287109375, "activeCells": 11, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.64453125, "edgeDensity": 0.05263157894736842, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-58-00-6175234b-257a-49d3-a27e-6d89ee409902", "generationId": "gen-1787597885-ihNCZ3Dwu2Q69hFCgkdL", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787597885-ihNCZ3Dwu2Q69hFCgkdL" ], "promptId": "light-clear-thought-v1", "prompt": "The first clear thought after confusion. Paint freely.", "title": "The first clear thought after confusion.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "thinkingmachines/inkling", "modelName": "Inkling", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92506, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-00-6175234b-257a-49d3-a27e-6d89ee409902/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-00-6175234b-257a-49d3-a27e-6d89ee409902/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "df1bde9a8cfc5a738a05deadee2ab4cff7b947bb92fcbcc6a7a3731bb472a164", "codeSha256": "dd70177ca6690cbe21ecb312ae4ecd0d3b380c377e6e7d1add881a55da633e59", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:58:20.198Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "Stacked translucent masses gather around one warm opening; simple and somewhat familiar, but the focal hierarchy and pale-field balance remain legible.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.3072, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 11, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 2, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6174, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0391, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 7 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 7 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 7 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.3071831597222222, "activeCells": 11, "valueBands": 2, "dominantColorRatio": 0.6174045138888888, "edgeDensity": 0.03914473684210526, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-49-17-e04d44e1-95d8-4277-b1b0-73204fa959dc", "generationId": "resp_07d1b740d5d4d4bf006a8c92625eb087d2896d302d2613ca99", "generationIds": [ "resp_07d1b740d5d4d4bf006a8c92625eb087d2896d302d2613ca99" ], "promptId": "light-carried-promise-v1", "prompt": "A promise that survives being carried. Paint freely.", "title": "A promise that survives being carried.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "gpt-5.6-luna", "modelName": "GPT-5.6 Luna", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92507, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-49-17-e04d44e1-95d8-4277-b1b0-73204fa959dc/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-49-17-e04d44e1-95d8-4277-b1b0-73204fa959dc/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "35b841e801d9fa01a9395304fd76b376cb04e9d857d304df9c814803395b0b69", "codeSha256": "fe5102c79d314727c740883ee20cea5d1da6e4af17afc5d2eaa4e864b736ae7d", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:50:45.031Z", "editorialStatus": "accepted", "editorialNote": "The suspended warm parcel and rising earth form an unusually specific answer without becoming literal; asymmetry, scale, and pale atmosphere are resolved.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 0.9091, "passed": 10, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2252, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 10, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.7259, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0539, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 2, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 47, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-review", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 47, "shapeCalls": 1 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 47, "shapeCalls": 1 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.2251519097222222, "activeCells": 10, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.7259114583333334, "edgeDensity": 0.05394736842105263, "activeHorizontalBands": 2 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-58-04-7103a2c5-cc36-404b-b302-ae8cb4e124c1", "generationId": "msg_05446f9d-d2ee-408f-9670-1a4f10353340", "generationIds": [ "msg_05446f9d-d2ee-408f-9670-1a4f10353340" ], "promptId": "light-carried-promise-v1", "prompt": "A promise that survives being carried. Paint freely.", "title": "A promise that survives being carried.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "qwen3.7-max", "modelName": "Qwen 3.7 Max", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92507, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-04-7103a2c5-cc36-404b-b302-ae8cb4e124c1/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-04-7103a2c5-cc36-404b-b302-ae8cb4e124c1/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "e9701411d0771239836442e8039f2ae32bb636025b3eaeae6ec9f35f56ca9a6f", "codeSha256": "c737f93b549eebcb6cddab89674fbf8c9bd1e681d9d95fb2baa46f63e27b3caa", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:58:57.860Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A translucent handled vessel shelters one warm circular core; immediately readable and balanced, if somewhat literal and object-like.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2844, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 10, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6615, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0689, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 7 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 7 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 2, "shapeCalls": 7 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.2843967013888889, "activeCells": 10, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.6614583333333334, "edgeDensity": 0.06891447368421053, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-53-14-5bc12dbc-ed20-4bd9-879b-d5cd827b1f27", "generationId": "msg_52dece16-5d38-44c4-8f0c-5c3155717c8a", "generationIds": [ "msg_52dece16-5d38-44c4-8f0c-5c3155717c8a" ], "promptId": "light-carried-promise-v1", "prompt": "A promise that survives being carried. Paint freely.", "title": "A promise that survives being carried.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "qwen3.8-max", "modelName": "Qwen 3.8 Max", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92507, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-53-14-5bc12dbc-ed20-4bd9-879b-d5cd827b1f27/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-53-14-5bc12dbc-ed20-4bd9-879b-d5cd827b1f27/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "17bca95e6078a5c079085f12da72a5a6744875c2ba9af5830635c6cfb2832dd9", "codeSha256": "aed569d8ae32b37606b7d89d29c3b6307b6dbdc63a46ce66520c12322a6435b9", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:54:46.255Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A softly weighted blue vessel rests on a curved support with a warm lip and quiet marks; competent and coherent, but conventional beside the campaign's strongest answers.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1938, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 9, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6944, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0504, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 9 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.1937934027777778, "activeCells": 9, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.6944444444444444, "edgeDensity": 0.05038377192982456, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-58-19-c181b37e-38d8-4d7d-907b-83f5021ed481", "generationId": "gen-1787597899-6DmDsH49PUT0r4OzON1r", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787597899-6DmDsH49PUT0r4OzON1r" ], "promptId": "light-carried-promise-v1", "prompt": "A promise that survives being carried. Paint freely.", "title": "A promise that survives being carried.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "thinkingmachines/inkling", "modelName": "Inkling", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92507, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-19-c181b37e-38d8-4d7d-907b-83f5021ed481/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-19-c181b37e-38d8-4d7d-907b-83f5021ed481/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "96574f7b6f5fddec9a68e4be82187459eb1439eb8edd96db991735b2f4e65e0a", "codeSha256": "dbd740b55ee33f7460d9b988568ed706da757f19a92af717522bba651db6b623", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:58:38.512Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A reclining or sheltered form holds a small warm center under a broad pale atmosphere; the unusual diagonal weight makes the promise feel physically carried.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2385, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 10, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.3212, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0471, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 2, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 5 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 5 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 5 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.2384982638888889, "activeCells": 10, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.3211805555555556, "edgeDensity": 0.047094298245614036, "activeHorizontalBands": 2 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T19-07-09-e2bb2be3-4007-4d37-a9ac-ac2c59704779", "generationId": "gen-1787598447-VgDnzXW6T3EHL6XanFCi", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787598447-VgDnzXW6T3EHL6XanFCi" ], "promptId": "light-carried-promise-v1", "prompt": "A promise that survives being carried. Paint freely.", "title": "A promise that survives being carried.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "thinkingmachines/inkling", "modelName": "Inkling", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92508, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-07-09-e2bb2be3-4007-4d37-a9ac-ac2c59704779/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-07-09-e2bb2be3-4007-4d37-a9ac-ac2c59704779/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "bede87d5dab6a9a2091798e38fc0622702f2eab41359332e04f29d79a474d843", "codeSha256": "025b2d5aebf89892906bf9619e03847e39163f68506d1fb02e21f7bb532e7cff", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T19:07:52.080Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "Offset pale masses gather around a tiny warm square like a fragile load being stabilized; modest, but the asymmetry and ground plane keep it intentional.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1829, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 10, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.7578, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.043, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 12 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 12 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 12 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.18294270833333334, "activeCells": 10, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.7578125, "edgeDensity": 0.04298245614035088, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T19-13-40-087327c5-51b8-4f93-b923-161db05cec2c", "generationId": "gen-1787598841-eQkEONuaFDAfWnzrm7WT", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787598826-cdp58EjyIv3oKosdwoFK", "gen-1787598841-eQkEONuaFDAfWnzrm7WT" ], "promptId": "light-making-sense-v1", "prompt": "The pleasure of making sense. Paint freely.", "title": "The pleasure of making sense.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "modelName": "Gemini 3.5 Flash Lite", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92508, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-13-40-087327c5-51b8-4f93-b923-161db05cec2c/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-13-40-087327c5-51b8-4f93-b923-161db05cec2c/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "005788b508a71d201154c4e0e93a019c2374bf68beb9ab813618193cb890a663", "codeSha256": "269f52ae32a075f13b25616743eada5f896bfd2a0c0430c56b15b095a94361e1", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T19:14:14.317Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "Interlocking ochre and coral planes visibly negotiate alignment while the pale ground remains quiet.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1492, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 7, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 2, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.8258, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0366, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 6 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 6 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 3, "shapeCalls": 6 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.1491970486111111, "activeCells": 7, "valueBands": 2, "dominantColorRatio": 0.8258463541666666, "edgeDensity": 0.03662280701754386, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-49-17-cc174024-1fcf-460c-b07e-f97737bf00dd", "generationId": "resp_0948ccd3f2a6f06e006a8c927c497887d28b0315f594f09494", "generationIds": [ "resp_0948ccd3f2a6f06e006a8c927c497887d28b0315f594f09494" ], "promptId": "light-making-sense-v1", "prompt": "The pleasure of making sense. Paint freely.", "title": "The pleasure of making sense.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "gpt-5.6-luna", "modelName": "GPT-5.6 Luna", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92508, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-49-17-cc174024-1fcf-460c-b07e-f97737bf00dd/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-49-17-cc174024-1fcf-460c-b07e-f97737bf00dd/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "67693031bfc2d6a1bc4e1b41ab386bb6a5009e3559c14703ea5de0c5755bae3c", "codeSha256": "85e13772bdf8ee6ca890d12763f5934e5a501007857fe4efa5ee2c3da2874024", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:51:08.814Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "The sail and hull resolve immediately as parts finding a shared direction; despite a familiar Luna boat motif, this light-field composition is materially distinct and well finished.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 0.9091, "passed": 10, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1901, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 9, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.7334, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.082, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 2, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 29, "shapeCalls": 3 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-review", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 29, "shapeCalls": 3 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 29, "shapeCalls": 3 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.19010416666666666, "activeCells": 9, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.7333984375, "edgeDensity": 0.08196271929824561, "activeHorizontalBands": 2 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-58-07-995b2a23-4b93-4225-8513-6917d81f799f", "generationId": "msg_ae8ce846-0dc6-4ee1-8aa4-1ddd9f8794cf", "generationIds": [ "msg_ae8ce846-0dc6-4ee1-8aa4-1ddd9f8794cf" ], "promptId": "light-making-sense-v1", "prompt": "The pleasure of making sense. Paint freely.", "title": "The pleasure of making sense.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "qwen3.7-max", "modelName": "Qwen 3.7 Max", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92508, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-07-995b2a23-4b93-4225-8513-6917d81f799f/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-07-995b2a23-4b93-4225-8513-6917d81f799f/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "7ed48698b91244aea9a8781ec02375974cb8424fa73279c03c9dc97615f0bfbe", "codeSha256": "9984e21d7f5f55e9d7735ca7dfebfc009a30ac8158106b7d55ec290dd01091e6", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:59:20.494Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "Intersecting translucent panels and ruled strokes behave like parts being aligned; busier than the best work, but the construction remains purposeful rather than random.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2252, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 14, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.4556, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0703, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 10, "shapeCalls": 8 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 10, "shapeCalls": 8 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 10, "shapeCalls": 8 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.2251519097222222, "activeCells": 14, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.4556206597222222, "edgeDensity": 0.07028508771929824, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-53-28-0f070c5c-a210-4c1e-bf16-30d55f07aa59", "generationId": "msg_2da8ff32-db61-4649-9775-131a07d70f17", "generationIds": [ "msg_2da8ff32-db61-4649-9775-131a07d70f17" ], "promptId": "light-making-sense-v1", "prompt": "The pleasure of making sense. Paint freely.", "title": "The pleasure of making sense.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "qwen3.8-max", "modelName": "Qwen 3.8 Max", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92508, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-53-28-0f070c5c-a210-4c1e-bf16-30d55f07aa59/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-53-28-0f070c5c-a210-4c1e-bf16-30d55f07aa59/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "b15955cc722487f5a5b1cc75f6e0933797dc407abc020bf7a9e3e6d7476106a3", "codeSha256": "fa54d5b9a9649920898e4eb7a978ac094d910e194f3321adafdf47fbc0bfc633", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:55:06.458Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "Three translucent planes interlock around a warm center with clear weight and spacing; modest, but sufficiently resolved and distinct for a comparative rail.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2014, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 9, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6259, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0394, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 6, "shapeCalls": 8 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 6, "shapeCalls": 8 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 6, "shapeCalls": 8 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.2013888888888889, "activeCells": 9, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.6258680555555556, "edgeDensity": 0.039364035087719296, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-49-54-794ec935-917e-42b5-976b-276d8a52c53b", "generationId": "resp_0b4437af0e01c08d006a8c9292693487d28e0e02d94d0aec4d", "generationIds": [ "resp_0b4437af0e01c08d006a8c9292693487d28e0e02d94d0aec4d" ], "promptId": "light-freedom-before-symbol-v1", "prompt": "Freedom before the symbol. Paint freely.", "title": "Freedom before the symbol.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "gpt-5.6-luna", "modelName": "GPT-5.6 Luna", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92509, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-49-54-794ec935-917e-42b5-976b-276d8a52c53b/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-49-54-794ec935-917e-42b5-976b-276d8a52c53b/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "144da3a71bc01c31b36540c312824c33d0602efd45822c397993ef25f54af35c", "codeSha256": "69439d18322f07fe3624e6d3cb44cd8a580ac5303e7ded6aef1cfd4aa156523f", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:51:30.427Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "The leaning feather-tree remains poised between object and gesture, an apt pre-symbolic answer with believable weight and ample quiet space.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 0.9091, "passed": 10, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1332, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 6, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6481, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0532, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 29, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-review", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 29, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 29, "shapeCalls": 9 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.1332465277777778, "activeCells": 6, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.6481119791666666, "edgeDensity": 0.05317982456140351, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T19-03-27-1d48f56d-48bc-4f33-9706-ea1a7f8dad56", "generationId": "06dbc89aa3d8bb7dc03cff8a53ae99a3", "generationIds": [ "06dbc89aa3d8bb7dc03cff8a53ae99a3" ], "promptId": "light-freedom-before-symbol-v1", "prompt": "Freedom before the symbol. Paint freely.", "title": "Freedom before the symbol.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "minimax-m3", "modelName": "MiniMax M3", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92509, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-03-27-1d48f56d-48bc-4f33-9706-ea1a7f8dad56/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-03-27-1d48f56d-48bc-4f33-9706-ea1a7f8dad56/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "36d62b0f4e7170340c2486f83e269f98f6e8aefdac64ac90dae8fc305fdf3d25", "codeSha256": "4711b7f837981646d57af7a4b31a86297e105959323549dcfa6f66ad23207265", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T19:04:44.132Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A broad translucent crown and grounded trunk preserve ambiguity between landscape, shelter, and free growth.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.4109, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 10, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 4, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.3796, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0568, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 6, "shapeCalls": 15 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 6, "shapeCalls": 15 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 6, "shapeCalls": 15 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.4109157986111111, "activeCells": 10, "valueBands": 4, "dominantColorRatio": 0.3795572916666667, "edgeDensity": 0.05679824561403509, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-53-57-df3dac7b-7963-4fc1-af58-7c5eb96681ef", "generationId": "msg_77e6bd32-fd2a-437c-b19a-985c2c48ad1c", "generationIds": [ "msg_77e6bd32-fd2a-437c-b19a-985c2c48ad1c" ], "promptId": "light-freedom-before-symbol-v1", "prompt": "Freedom before the symbol. Paint freely.", "title": "Freedom before the symbol.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "qwen3.8-max", "modelName": "Qwen 3.8 Max", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92509, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-53-57-df3dac7b-7963-4fc1-af58-7c5eb96681ef/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-53-57-df3dac7b-7963-4fc1-af58-7c5eb96681ef/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "d0e8b8d01eb991148919f652174b7000aeb8315d02ed7d976d35d92da0fc8b7e", "codeSha256": "384bebb7f610d8413254793d0509638f2bab44eeb6f35bc81820fed70f6d57a0", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:55:38.170Z", "editorialStatus": "accepted", "editorialNote": "A salmon-colored leaf, wing, or body lifts diagonally away from blue ground; the ambiguity, thrust, and off-center scale embody motion before settling into a symbol.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2968, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 12, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 4, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.5766, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0868, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 10 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 10 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 10 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.2967664930555556, "activeCells": 12, "valueBands": 4, "dominantColorRatio": 0.5766059027777778, "edgeDensity": 0.08678728070175439, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-58-38-fdcc1ee1-b7ce-4a73-a138-5f799850e923", "generationId": "gen-1787597920-X5qAlTmwLiuggiiAeLOQ", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787597920-X5qAlTmwLiuggiiAeLOQ" ], "promptId": "light-freedom-before-symbol-v1", "prompt": "Freedom before the symbol. Paint freely.", "title": "Freedom before the symbol.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "thinkingmachines/inkling", "modelName": "Inkling", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92509, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-38-fdcc1ee1-b7ce-4a73-a138-5f799850e923/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-38-fdcc1ee1-b7ce-4a73-a138-5f799850e923/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "8c5988fd371627d1ce799709bfa3818d1848a949774b3e37408cf7fffde460d5", "codeSha256": "5b4fb24d4b9ea1a168fb1de6ba580874d895fb5ba6aa3fc50c080087689cb912", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:59:25.829Z", "editorialStatus": "accepted", "editorialNote": "A poised airborne or seated form is caught between bird, ribbon, and gesture; the gold turn, floating joints, and broad quiet field answer freedom without settling into a fixed symbol.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.3237, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 10, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6179, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0473, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 9 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.3236762152777778, "activeCells": 10, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.6179470486111112, "edgeDensity": 0.04731359649122807, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T19-13-46-8ec89822-ea4c-443b-923f-c99bbe4a625b", "generationId": "gen-1787598836-gnOV3obJ8FbAIdWV7GYY", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787598836-gnOV3obJ8FbAIdWV7GYY" ], "promptId": "light-heart-desires-v1", "prompt": "Draw whatever you want.", "title": "Draw whatever you want.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "google/gemini-3.5-flash-lite", "modelName": "Gemini 3.5 Flash Lite", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92510, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-13-46-8ec89822-ea4c-443b-923f-c99bbe4a625b/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-13-46-8ec89822-ea4c-443b-923f-c99bbe4a625b/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "fdd8f884cd6b70aa507d977d607ad3f4ad3c8f7149632ee7a4b51686d38b45fa", "codeSha256": "4ad68ad3d3fe1b2801cdb3e6b16ca55292bfbf8e50875b0e890229643875d591", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T19:14:12.053Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "Offset warm and cool planes produce a poised abstract shelter with a small, deliberate center of gravity.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2926, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 12, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 4, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6942, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0833, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 7, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 7, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 7, "shapeCalls": 9 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.2926432291666667, "activeCells": 12, "valueBands": 4, "dominantColorRatio": 0.6942274305555556, "edgeDensity": 0.08327850877192983, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-50-23-6e75bbd7-523e-4eee-ba59-f7ad4870ac71", "generationId": "resp_05869590238576d1006a8c92ab6b2887d2814da0d0ed2b1350", "generationIds": [ "resp_05869590238576d1006a8c92ab6b2887d2814da0d0ed2b1350" ], "promptId": "light-heart-desires-v1", "prompt": "Draw whatever you want.", "title": "Draw whatever you want.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "gpt-5.6-luna", "modelName": "GPT-5.6 Luna", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92510, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-50-23-6e75bbd7-523e-4eee-ba59-f7ad4870ac71/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-50-23-6e75bbd7-523e-4eee-ba59-f7ad4870ac71/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "345b7528d2460f7cb4fb6e91aa8a552f9ecc9be6914aba01ab586ea4fa37f1de", "codeSha256": "6582e2460a5cb3aa22d94e9f18e242e96311a6a28ba936ec5725ffb887230dcf", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:51:58.688Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A calm branching tree with three translucent crowns is compositionally complete and readable, though more familiar and less surprising than the strongest Luna canvases.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 0.9091, "passed": 10, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.1604, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 12, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.7174, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0692, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 28, "shapeCalls": 4 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-review", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": false, "observed": { "lineCalls": 28, "shapeCalls": 4 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 28, "shapeCalls": 4 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.1603732638888889, "activeCells": 12, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.7174479166666666, "edgeDensity": 0.06918859649122808, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-58-38-8a726fcf-3b78-4b70-9ec0-0f4397a12a0e", "generationId": "msg_11f82d69-7e3b-405b-b89e-c502c1fc90a7", "generationIds": [ "msg_11f82d69-7e3b-405b-b89e-c502c1fc90a7" ], "promptId": "light-heart-desires-v1", "prompt": "Draw whatever you want.", "title": "Draw whatever you want.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "qwen3.7-max", "modelName": "Qwen 3.7 Max", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92510, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-38-8a726fcf-3b78-4b70-9ec0-0f4397a12a0e/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-58-38-8a726fcf-3b78-4b70-9ec0-0f4397a12a0e/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "93a8945b50fde885762bc9dffc84f6637ccff817c6fe49e956a0626a5f7115fb", "codeSha256": "b7304e050c8b7756508ceeb6822d22d27b0fddc2a7953ac6c7f3a8f701b90bef", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T19:00:06.988Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "The bottle-like body with green inset and narrow amber side passage is calm and finished, though it repeats a familiar vessel grammar.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.2337, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 10, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.7223, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0449, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 1, "shapeCalls": 10 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 1, "shapeCalls": 10 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 1, "shapeCalls": 10 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.23372395833333334, "activeCells": 10, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.7223307291666666, "edgeDensity": 0.044901315789473685, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-54-46-6e7617a1-7432-4679-bc08-6db912109d25", "generationId": "msg_6210b998-69ca-4efe-aa19-1d057bff83eb", "generationIds": [ "msg_6210b998-69ca-4efe-aa19-1d057bff83eb" ], "promptId": "light-heart-desires-v1", "prompt": "Draw whatever you want.", "title": "Draw whatever you want.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "opencode-go", "providerName": "OpenCode Go", "model": "qwen3.8-max", "modelName": "Qwen 3.8 Max", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92510, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-54-46-6e7617a1-7432-4679-bc08-6db912109d25/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-54-46-6e7617a1-7432-4679-bc08-6db912109d25/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "164d8fd36026f85933f29e9ebf0b4764559239d800358a0cb1e71bb641ad8b12", "codeSha256": "7c0d9867cf6b710d1748b9dfee303fb73b39a5de051a848789b2876c10a9ac11", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:56:24.094Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A pale house or shelter frames a darker inner door and tiny amber object; quiet and spatially legible, though the familiar enclosure motif limits surprise.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.3453, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 10, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.4466, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0571, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 11 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 11 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 0, "shapeCalls": 11 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.3452690972222222, "activeCells": 10, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.4466145833333333, "edgeDensity": 0.05712719298245614, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T18-59-25-efdc2331-4b5f-4375-b64f-c5308f562cfa", "generationId": "gen-1787597966-J0NIUWTqViW0MJBFDyGg", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787597966-J0NIUWTqViW0MJBFDyGg" ], "promptId": "light-heart-desires-v1", "prompt": "Draw whatever you want.", "title": "Draw whatever you want.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "thinkingmachines/inkling", "modelName": "Inkling", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92510, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-59-25-efdc2331-4b5f-4375-b64f-c5308f562cfa/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T18-59-25-efdc2331-4b5f-4375-b64f-c5308f562cfa/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "a98a5a4d8630fbc37bcd2e4e3d64418ab1f55de555bcb7bf95ec260573e5078a", "codeSha256": "2f956c4eb993b105a54986722426ce895134bb0713199e3cc7acab373007a123", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T18:59:46.181Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "A solitary translucent vessel stands in cool mist above a warm broken ground; understated but atmospheric, with enough tonal separation to hold at full size.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.6742, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 15, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.26, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0453, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 5, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 5, "shapeCalls": 9 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 5, "shapeCalls": 9 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.6741536458333334, "activeCells": 15, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.2599826388888889, "edgeDensity": 0.04528508771929825, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } }, { "attemptId": "2026-08-24T19-07-52-d340645e-1800-4fe8-8f15-c66e9f5ecbc5", "generationId": "gen-1787598523-XpGvYbVe161fHGNWWLcg", "generationIds": [ "gen-1787598523-XpGvYbVe161fHGNWWLcg" ], "promptId": "light-heart-desires-v1", "prompt": "Draw whatever you want.", "title": "Draw whatever you want.", "field": "light", "promptProfile": "singular-canvas-v2", "provider": "openrouter", "providerName": "OpenRouter", "model": "thinkingmachines/inkling", "modelName": "Inkling", "medium": "gouache", "paper": "white", "seed": 92511, "canvas": { "width": 600, "height": 600, "scale": 3, "outputWidth": 1800, "outputHeight": 1800 }, "image": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-07-52-d340645e-1800-4fe8-8f15-c66e9f5ecbc5/painting.png", "source": "/images/model-authored-paintings-v2/2026-08-24T19-07-52-d340645e-1800-4fe8-8f15-c66e9f5ecbc5/sketch.js.txt", "imageSha256": "88a8f78b7f3a2bbbcdda3a3c758bae5a7a23fde1ce9e9a551492d9c7a877aab6", "codeSha256": "aafa27d26a3e57d6349ab40220f58f93fcc03b293f81771c2f7ab2e8ea112fb0", "generatedAt": "2026-08-24T19:09:02.371Z", "editorialStatus": "comparison", "editorialNote": "Two warm-gray stones balance as a quiet figure beneath a broad pale cloud; familiar, but proportion, ground weight, and sparse marks are held with care.", "tools": [ "p5.js", "p5.brush", "local Chromium renderer" ], "renderer": "vendored-p5.brush+atelier-v2-composition+offscreen-composite+centroid-fallback-fix", "quality": { "status": "automated-pass", "score": 1, "passed": 11, "total": 11, "checks": [ { "id": "output-resolution", "label": "true large-canvas raster", "pass": true, "observed": "1800x1800", "expected": ">=1600x1200" }, { "id": "variation-coverage", "label": "deliberate paint variation across the canvas", "pass": true, "observed": 0.3971, "expected": ">=0.08" }, { "id": "spatial-occupancy", "label": "resolved 4x4 spatial field", "pass": true, "observed": 11, "expected": ">=5/16" }, { "id": "value-structure", "label": "meaningful value bands", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2" }, { "id": "background-dominance", "label": "background does not collapse into one flat colour", "pass": true, "observed": 0.4608, "expected": "<=0.88" }, { "id": "edge-density", "label": "detail is neither empty nor noisy", "pass": true, "observed": 0.0491, "expected": "0.015-0.3" }, { "id": "depth-bands", "label": "top, middle, and foreground carry intentional structure", "pass": true, "observed": 3, "expected": ">=2/3" }, { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 5, "shapeCalls": 10 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "composition": { "status": "composition-pass", "profile": "daylight-strict", "checks": [ { "id": "horizontal-band-risk", "label": "no stacked horizontal glaze-band shortcut", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<4", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "stochastic-filler-risk", "label": "field helpers are bounded and subordinate", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<5", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "blob-mass-risk", "label": "organic masses do not replace subject construction", "pass": true, "observed": 0, "expected": "<10 unless edge density is quiet", "severity": "review" }, { "id": "ungrounded-mark-risk", "label": "marks have connected painted support", "pass": true, "observed": { "lineCalls": 5, "shapeCalls": 10 }, "expected": "shape support for line marks", "severity": "review" } ], "sourceCounts": { "glazeCalls": 0, "fieldCalls": 0, "organicCalls": 0, "lineCalls": 5, "shapeCalls": 10 } }, "thresholds": { "minOutputWidth": 1600, "minOutputHeight": 1200, "minVariationCoverage": 0.08, "minActiveCells": 5, "minValueBands": 2, "maxDominantColorRatio": 0.88, "minEdgeDensity": 0.015, "maxEdgeDensity": 0.3, "minActiveHorizontalBands": 2 }, "metrics": { "sample": { "width": 96, "height": 96 }, "variationCoverage": 0.3971354166666667, "activeCells": 11, "valueBands": 3, "dominantColorRatio": 0.4608289930555556, "edgeDensity": 0.04906798245614035, "activeHorizontalBands": 3 }, "editorial": { "status": "pending", "rubricVersion": "artist-canvas-taste-v1" } }, "provenance": { "experimentId": "2026-08-24-full-code-nocturne-v2", "promptSpec": "singular-canvas-v2", "directionId": null, "recoveredExactResponse": false, "providerCallMade": true, "parentAttemptId": null, "sourceResponseFile": null } } ] }